Overview

Walk down the cat treats aisle at any pet store and Temptations is almost impossible to miss — it’s the best-selling cat treat brand in North America, and the tub shape and crinkly stay-fresh pouch have become shorthand for “treat time” in a lot of households. The Tasty Chicken Flavor 16 oz. tub reviewed here is the brand’s flagship everyday size, built for owners who reward their cat multiple times a day without worrying about calories piling up.

The dual-texture design is the mechanical reason it works: a crisp outer shell wrapped around a soft, slightly creamy center, rather than the flat crunch of a basic kibble-style treat. It’s a simple idea, but it’s the reason Temptations built a category around itself rather than just competing inside the existing one — and it’s the same treat Canadian owners will find stocked at Canadian pet retailers and on Amazon.ca.

Key Specifications

Temptations Classic Crunchy Cat Treats Palatability & Texture

Palatability is the entire premise of this product, and it’s where the brand’s #1 sales ranking actually shows up in practice. Mars Petcare markets the treat as designed to make cats “come running the moment you open the pack,” and that reputation is echoed constantly across Amazon and Chewy customer reviews, where the most common complaint isn’t that cats dislike the treat — it’s that cats become demanding about getting more of it.

The crunchy-shell, soft-center combination is the mechanical reason for that response: it gives a cat two different textures and a burst of flavor in a single bite, rather than the flat crunch of a basic kibble-style treat. At under 2 calories each, the format also supports frequent, small-quantity rewarding — useful for training sessions or multiple daily treat moments — without the calorie math getting out of hand the way it can with larger training treats.

Ingredient Quality & Nutrition

This is the category’s honest trade-off. Temptations’ ingredient list leans on chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, and ground corn rather than the single-source, whole-meat-first formulas found in premium or limited-ingredient treats. It’s labeled “100% nutritionally complete and balanced for adult cat maintenance,” which is a real formulation claim, but it isn’t a grain-free or novel-protein product, and owners managing a food sensitivity or chasing a cleaner ingredient panel will want to check the label against their vet’s guidance before switching.

For a cat with no dietary restrictions, though, the formulation isn’t a practical problem — it’s simply a mass-market treat rather than a boutique one, priced and marketed accordingly.

Value & Packaging Options

At approx. $29.44 CAD for the 16 oz. tub, and with each treat weighing in at well under 2 calories, the effective per-treat cost works out to a fraction of a cent — genuinely difficult to beat for a treat this widely available. The stay-fresh pouch/tub format also keeps the batch crisp between uses, which matters more than it sounds like once a tub has been open for a few weeks.

The bigger value lever is size flexibility: Temptations sells the same formula in everything from 1 oz. trial pouches to 48 oz. bulk bags, so a household with one cat and a household with four can both buy into the format without over- or under-committing on a first purchase.

How Does It Stack Up Against the Competition?

Temptations competes against a mix of lickable purées, dental-focused treats, and other crunchy formats — each solving a slightly different job.

Is the Temptations Classic Crunchy Cat Treats Worth It?

Temptations Classic Crunchy Cat Treats are built around one job: getting an enthusiastic response from nearly any cat, and the brand’s #1 sales ranking in North America backs that up. The dual-texture treat — crunchy shell, soft center — combined with a sub-2-calorie count per piece makes it easy to reward frequently without derailing a diet, and the range of sizes from 1 oz. to 48 oz. means it scales from a single trial pouch to a multi-cat household without friction.

The ingredient list leans on meat by-products and grain fillers rather than the single-source proteins found in premium options like Blue Buffalo Bursts, so owners specifically chasing a grain-free or limited-ingredient treat should look elsewhere.

Still comparing cat treat options? See our Best Cat Treats 2026 guide →Still comparing cat treat options? See our Best Cat Treats 2026 guide →

GuideBest Cat Treats 2026: 3 Top Picks ComparedRead the Guide →

Sarah MitchellSenior Editor 𝕏

Sarah has spent more than a few decades — she's not saying how many — in home design, with a sharp eye for products that deliver real quality without the inflated price tag. Her passion is finding the hidden gem that makes everyday life genuinely better.

Content produced with AI-assisted research — editorial policy →