How We Review Products
Our Research Process, Rating Criteria & Editorial Standards
Our Approach
Most products have already been tested by somebody: lab testers measure them, expert reviewers live with them, and owners report back months later. Our job is to bring that evidence together, so you don’t have to read ten reviews to find out where they agree and where they don’t.
Every review we publish follows the same process, whatever the category, price or brand, and answers the questions a buyer actually has: Does it do what it claims? Is it worth the money? What are the most common problems? How does it compare to the alternatives?
Why Many Sources Beat One
- Agreement is a stronger signal. One reviewer tests one unit for a few days. When several independent testers reach the same finding, it’s far less likely to be a fluke.
- Measurements beat impressions. Where labs have measured something — battery runtime, noise reduction, suction, brightness — we use their numbers, which compare fairly across products in a way adjectives can’t.
- Time shows what launch reviews can’t. Most reviews are written in a product’s first weeks. What owners report months later shows how it holds up.
- Disagreements are worth knowing. When testers split, we name who found what rather than averaging it away, so you can decide which finding matches how you’d use it.
The Four Research Inputs
1. Independent Tests and Expert Reviews
We start with what independent testers found: lab measurements where they exist, and hands-on reviews from established outlets. Articles published or updated since October 2026 list a median of 14 sources each, every one named in the article’s Sources section.
2. Manufacturer Specifications
Specifications, official documentation and retailer listings across both US and Canadian markets, cross-referenced across sources, with discrepancies noted. A maker’s figure is labelled as the maker’s claim, and we say when testers measured something different.
3. Owner Experience Over Time
We use AI to read large volumes of owner reviews and owner communities for patterns — common failure points, consistently praised strengths, use-case limitations — that a handful of launch reviews can’t show. When we’ve used a product ourselves, bought or received as a manufacturer sample, the review says so.
4. Checks Before Publishing
Before publication, automated checks look for testing claims we can’t support, contradictions and filler, and a separate fact-check verifies the article against its sources (see How We Check the Facts below). Drafts that fail are fixed or not published.
Inside One Review: Apple AirPods 5
Our AirPods 5 review (October 2026) shows how this works in practice:
- 27 sources, including 11 independent reviewers such as SoundGuys, Tom’s Guide, Trusted Reviews and Engadget, alongside Apple’s specifications.
- Where they agreed: among open-fit earbuds, no tester we read had heard better noise cancelling, and SoundGuys’ lab measured an average 59% drop in how loud outside noise seemed. The same measurements showed the weak spot, deep engine rumble under 500 Hz.
- Where they split: on flights, Gizmodo’s reviewer slept through a cross-country trip while BGR heard the engines the whole way; on runs, some testers didn’t trust the fit while Tom’s Guide’s fitness editor ran 22 miles in them. The review names each.
- What nobody had measured yet: no review had run the standard model’s battery down, so the review gives Apple’s rating, says so, and doesn’t guess.
How We Check the Facts
Since October 2026, every article we publish or update goes through these steps before it can go live. Older articles get the same treatment as we update them.
- A saved research trail. Each source the article relies on is saved as a dated copy, so every claim can be traced back to what the source actually said on the day we read it.
- Claims tied to their sources. Each finding we credit to a source, each quote and each point we describe as widely shared is recorded with the passage that supports it.
- Automatic checks. Software confirms that quotes appear word for word in the source they’re credited to, that figures match their source, that no passage copies a source’s wording, that every source we name is listed in the article’s Sources section, and that every product in a comparison is a real, currently sold model.
- A separate fact-checker. A second AI, separate from the one that wrote the article, re-reads the draft against the saved sources. It looks for claims stated more strongly than the evidence, specs that belong to a different model or size, sources that disagree, and any negative claim without a primary source. The article can’t publish until its findings are fixed and it passes.
How we use sources. When several sources agree, we say so in our own words. When a finding comes from one source — its own measurement, its verdict, or a point where sources disagree — we name it. Quotes are short, exact and marked as quotes. Every article lists its sources.
How We Score Products
We rate products on a 5-point scale (1.0 to 5.0). Scores reflect overall value to the target buyer — not a checkbox of features. A $49 air fryer that does exactly what a budget buyer needs can score higher than a $200 model that underdelivers on its premium promise.
Every score comes from our own consistent formula, applied the same way to every product and never picked by feel. It balances three things:
- How well it does the job it’s bought for. Each product is judged on what matters for its specific use (for a robot vacuum, things like cleaning power, navigation and battery life), based on lab and expert tests and long-term owner experience.
- Value for money. What you get for the price, compared with the alternatives.
- The competition. How it stacks up against the other products in the review’s comparison, so a real shortfall on something that matters holds a score down, however well the product does elsewhere.
A product’s US and Canadian reviews carry the same score, because it’s the same product, and our buying guides show the score from each product’s own review. Scores are not permanent: when we revisit a review because of new evidence, a new version or a major price change, we recalculate its score.
Prices
A review’s value score uses the price we found when we researched it. The price tables show Amazon’s current price, fetched directly from Amazon’s product data for both US and Canadian listings and refreshed throughout the day; if Amazon’s data isn’t available for a product, the table shows the most recent price we’ve recorded, with its date. Where Amazon offers a Prime-member price, that’s the price shown. Prices and availability change often, so always check the current price on the retailer’s site before buying.
US vs. Canadian Reviews
Where a product is sold in Canada, we publish a Canadian edition of its review. Canadian reviews are adapted from the US review of the same product and checked the same way: they use Amazon.ca pricing and availability (or the maker’s official Canadian price, with a note, when Amazon.ca doesn’t sell it) and add Canadian details such as certifications, warranty terms and where to buy. The rating matches the US review, because the product is the same.
Where the Canadian version of a product differs from the US version, the Canadian review says so.
Update Policy
Product reviews have a shelf life. We revisit published reviews when:
- A significant volume of new user data emerges that changes the reliability picture
- The manufacturer releases a new version or a material update
- The product’s price changes enough to affect the value assessment
- A reader submits a credible correction or flags a factual error
Each review shows the date it was reviewed, and an “Updated” date when it has been substantially revised since. That date does not indicate ongoing monitoring. Prices and availability should be verified independently before purchasing.
How We Use AI
AI does the reading and the writing: it gathers and summarises the research, cross-references specifications across sources, and writes the article. The sources, research standards, scoring formula and checks are ours: our editors set them, and they handle corrections.
Articles publish automatically once they pass those checks; they are not individually reviewed or edited by a person before publication, and most products are not tested by us. We think readers deserve to know this.
Every review, guide and First Look shows our affiliate disclosure at the top and, at the end, how it was made: the sources it draws on, the check it passed, and whether we tested the product. We believe this transparency is a minimum standard for AI-assisted publishing.
Commercial Independence
We earn revenue through affiliate commissions. This is disclosed at the top of every article and on our Affiliate Disclosure page. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. No manufacturer, retailer or advertiser influences our ratings or conclusions, and affiliate revenue does not influence them either. We don’t accept payment for reviews, rankings or placements. When a manufacturer gives us a product sample, the review says so.
Questions or Corrections
If you believe a review contains an error, or if you have a question about our methodology, use our Contact page. We read every message. To report an error, see our corrections policy.