Cuisinart ICE-21C Review: Creamy Ice Cream on a Budget

Cuisinart ICE-21P1 1.5-quart frozen-bowl ice cream maker
★ Bottom Line

If you want to try homemade ice cream without a big outlay or a big machine, the ICE-21C, sold on Amazon.ca, is the one to buy: it turns out dense, creamy ice cream in about 20 minutes with nothing more than an on/off switch, and Cuisinart backs it with a 3-year warranty in Canada. Test kitchens keep ranking its results among the best they have tried. The trade-off is planning: the bowl needs a day in the freezer, so you get one batch per freeze unless you add a spare bowl. If you want ice cream on a whim, the Whynter ICM-200LS chills itself.

Pros

  • Smooth, dense ice cream testers rank among the best
  • Batches in about 15 to 20 minutes
  • One switch and a wide opening for mix-ins
  • Light, compact base
  • Limited 3-year warranty

Cons

  • Bowl needs a day in the freezer: one batch per freeze
  • Small bowl can overflow with mix-ins
  • Not quiet while churning
  • Freezer bowl is hand-wash only and must thaw first

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure

Overview

You don’t need a countertop compressor to make very good ice cream at home. The Cuisinart ICE-21C, the Canadian edition of the ICE-21P1, is a small freezer-bowl machine: you freeze its insulated bowl ahead of time, pour in a chilled base, flip one switch, and it churns soft-serve-textured ice cream, frozen yogurt or sorbet. It’s for people who make ice cream now and then and want great results without giving up much counter space, and Amazon.ca sells it in white.

In Canada the same machine is sold as the ICE-21C. Cuisinart Canada lists it with the same 1.4 L (1½-quart) bowl and the same churn time of 20 minutes or less. Its Canadian booklet carries a limited 3-year warranty, with registration on Cuisinart’s Canadian site and a Canadian toll-free service line instead of a return to the store. Its record with testers carries over too: Wirecutter has named the ICE-21 its top pick after testing 24 ice cream makers over the years, and America’s Test Kitchen rates it the best canister-style maker.

Built from 15 sources, including 5 independent reviewers such as Wirecutter, CNN Underscored and TechGearLab. Here’s where they agree, and where they don’t.

Where the reviews agree

  • It makes smooth, dense, creamy ice cream that testers rank among the best from any home machine.
  • Churning is quick: most batches reach a soft-serve texture in roughly 15 to 20 minutes.
  • One on/off switch and an open top for pouring and mix-ins make it very simple to use.

Where they split

  • Noise: CNN Underscored found it one of the loudest machines it tested, while Dream Scoops took readings between 82 and 79 decibels and didn’t find it especially noisy.
  • Spare bowls: CNN Underscored said Cuisinart didn’t offer a replacement bowl, but Cuisinart Canada’s ICE-21C booklet says extra freezer bowls can be bought from cuisinart.ca.

Key Specifications

Price (CAD) Deal $61.59 until Nov 30
Model ICE-21C (Canadian edition of the ICE-21P1)
Type Double-insulated freezer bowl (no ice or salt needed)
Capacity Up to 1.4 L (1½ quarts)
Churn time (maker) 20 minutes or less
Bowl freezing time (maker) Generally 16 to 24 hours, freezer set to -18°C (0°F)
Controls On/off switch
Dimensions 24 x 23 x 29 cm (9.5 x 9 x 11.25 in, L x W x H)
Cleaning Hand-wash bowl, paddle and lid; freezer bowl not dishwasher-safe
Warranty Limited 3-year

Cuisinart ICE-21 Ice Cream Quality

This is the reason to buy it: the ice cream it makes is among the best a home machine turns out. It comes out dense, rich and smooth, with very little iciness. Wirecutter noted a slight chew and only a little iciness even in a tricky vegan base, and CNN Underscored found it one of the smoothest it tasted, with among the least buildup on the bowl wall.

Dream Scoops goes furthest: it ranks the ICE-21 above every machine it has tried except the Lello 4080 Musso Lussino, which usually costs around ten times as much. Other testers still give compressor machines the edge on the finest texture: in Wirecutter’s testing, the Whynter compressor models froze more steadily, while the ICE-21 gradually warms as it churns, and their faster paddles made smaller, less noticeable ice crystals.

Expect a soft-serve texture straight from the machine. Testers found it usually needs a rest in the freezer to firm up, and Cuisinart’s own recipes suggest about 2 hours for a firmer scoop.

Churn Speed and Controls

Once the bowl is frozen, making a batch is quick and close to foolproof. Cuisinart rates it at 20 minutes or less, and test batches mostly finished in about 15 to 20 minutes. Wirecutter found its churn time was half that of the compressor models it recommends, and the short churn helps give the ice cream its dense texture.

There is almost nothing to learn: a single on/off switch, and the base goes in through the spout once the bowl is turning. The open top is the other convenience. Cuisinart says to add chips or nuts about 5 minutes before the end, in pieces no larger than a chocolate chip. The opening makes that easy: Wirecutter puts it at about 9 cm (3.5 inches), where many machines have a slot barely wider than a spoon.

It isn’t quiet. CNN Underscored rated it among the loudest machines it tested, loud enough that you’d need to turn up the TV in a living room next to the kitchen, though the short churn keeps the noise brief. Dream Scoops took readings between 82 and 79 decibels over a batch and didn’t find it especially noisy.

Planning, Capacity and Cleanup

The price of that simplicity is planning ahead. Cuisinart says the bowl generally needs 16 to 24 hours in a freezer set to -18°C (0°F), and the bowl has warmed too much after churning for a second round, so you get one batch per freeze unless you own a spare bowl. Cuisinart’s tip is to shake the bowl: if you can’t hear the liquid inside moving, it’s frozen. TechGearLab got good results with a bowl frozen for at least eight hours and the ingredients pre-chilled. Keeping the bowl in the freezer all season makes spur-of-the-moment ice cream much easier.

The 1.4 L (1½-quart) bowl suits small households. Cuisinart’s vanilla recipe makes about 1.25 L (5 cups), and the manual says not to fill the bowl higher than 6 mm (¼ inch) from the top because the mix grows as it freezes. Wirecutter found a full recipe plus mix-ins can push ice cream up toward the cover, so it’s worth underfilling a little if you like add-ins. One of its long-term testers, after six years of use, wished the batch were larger.

Cleanup is easy but slow, because the bowl has to thaw first: TechGearLab notes that hot water can damage the cooling liquid inside, while cold water freezes onto it. After that, everything is a quick hand wash, and Cuisinart warns never to put the freezer bowl in the dishwasher. Wirecutter’s other long-term tester, after about two years, called cleaning easy once the bowl melts. The base is light and compact on the counter, though one tester found it a little bulky for a small cabinet. Cuisinart backs the machine with a limited 3-year warranty.

How Does It Stack Up Against the Competition?

The ICE-21 is the compact, simple choice; each rival makes a different trade on how it chills, how much it makes and how much planning it asks for.

Feature Cuisinart ICE-21C / ICE-21P1 Hamilton Beach 68330N Ninja CREAMi Whynter ICM-200LS
Price (CAD) Deal $61.59 until Nov 30 $98.61 $279.99 $448.24
How it chills Pre-frozen insulated bowl Ice and rock salt around the canister Spins a base frozen solid in a pint Built-in compressor
Capacity Up to 1.4 L (1½ quarts) 3.8 L (4 quarts) 473 mL (16-oz) pints 2 L (2.1 quarts)
Prep before churning Freeze the bowl 16 to 24 hours Ice and rock salt on hand Freeze the base in the pint No pre-freezing
Controls On/off switch Fully automatic, stops when ready 7 programs LCD timer
TTP ReviewThis review ↑—Read our review →Read our review →
AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on Amazon

Prices change frequently — always verify current pricing before purchasing.

Cuisinart ICE-21: Worth It for Small Batches of Rich Ice Cream

For a Canadian household that makes ice cream a few times a season, this is the machine to start with. The results rank with the best testers have tried, and a batch takes about the time it takes to clear the dinner table. As of November 2026 the ice-and-salt Hamilton Beach 68330N costs about the same as the ICE-21C on Amazon.ca, and in return it makes 3.8 L (4-quart) batches, where the ICE-21C needs no ice or rock salt.

Look elsewhere if you make ice cream often or for crowds. As of November 2026 the Whynter ICM-200LS costs several times as much, and in return its built-in compressor needs no frozen bowl and can keep churning batch after batch, with 2 L (2.1 quarts) of capacity. The Hamilton Beach 68330N needs no frozen bowl either: it makes 3.8 L (4 quarts) at a time, batch after batch, as long as you have ice and rock salt, though it’s loud and messy to run. The Ninja CREAMi works differently, spinning a pint you froze earlier, and Reviewed praises its versatility for all kinds of frozen treats, though CNN Underscored’s first dairy batch came out icy until it was re-spun.

Cuisinart ICE-21C
Cuisinart ICE-21C

On sale $61.59 until Nov 30

Read Amazon Reviews →

Reader Poll

What would make you buy a freezer-bowl ice cream maker like the ICE-21?

Help Our Editors Know What Matters to You

Sarah Mitchell
Sarah MitchellSenior Editor

Sarah has spent more than a few decades — she's not saying how many — in home design, with a sharp eye for products that deliver real quality without the inflated price tag. Her passion is finding the hidden gem that makes everyday life genuinely better.

How this was made: Built from the 15 sources listed above, including 5 independent reviewers such as Wirecutter, CNN Underscored and TechGearLab. AI drafts written to our editorial research and citation standards, then checked claim by claim against those sources by a separate AI fact-checker. We haven’t tested this product ourselves. How we review →

Similar Posts