AirPods 5 vs AirPods 4 ANC: When the Upgrade Pays Off

This AirPods 5 vs AirPods 4 comparison is for people who own the AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation. Apple stopped selling both AirPods 4 models in September 2026, when it announced the AirPods 5, so the real question is whether to replace a pair you already have. The two generations share the same tipless shape, H2 chip and rated battery life with cancelling on, which leaves four things to weigh: how much quieter the new pair gets, whether it sounds better to you, how your battery is holding up, and what happens to your charging case.

How the Two Compare

What They Have in Common

The AirPods 5 reuse the AirPods 4’s bud: the same shape, the same 4.3 g weight, the same driver and amplifier, so if your AirPods 4 sit well in your ears, the new pair will too, and if they don’t, nothing about the fit has changed. Both rest in the outer ear without tips, run on the H2 chip over Bluetooth 5.3, and offer Adaptive Audio, Transparency mode, Conversation Awareness and Personalized Spatial Audio. With an Apple Intelligence iPhone, both handle Live Translation and work with Apple’s new Siri AI (in beta), and since iOS 27 both have a simple custom EQ. Five minutes in either case gives about an hour of listening.

How Much Quieter Will the AirPods 5 Be?

Stronger cancelling is the headline change. Apple claims the AirPods 5 remove up to 50% more outside noise than the AirPods 4 with ANC and says it tested to the IEC 60268-24 standard, but, as Headphonesty pointed out, it hasn’t published the measurements or the calculation behind the figure. The tests since launch agree the new pair cancels more and disagree on how much. SoundGuys measured an average 59% drop in how loud outside noise seemed, a better result than it recorded from the AirPods 4. Of the outlets that switched between the two pairs, Trusted Reviews called the AirPods 5 “a clear step up”, above all with high-pitched noise such as a passing train; Gizmodo heard more street noise blocked, with subway rumble only slightly reduced; and Tom’s Guide found them “slightly better, but only slightly”, still hearing its own typing with either pair.

Testers differ on deep rumble. In SoundGuys’ tests the lowest bass tended to get through the AirPods 4, and the AirPods 5 did little below 500 Hz, the range of engine noise. What Hi-Fi, by contrast, found the rumble of engines and trains disappeared with the AirPods 4, and T3 found the AirPods 5 suppressed general rumble well.

Upgrade if steady background noise on buses, trains or in an open office still bothers you with the AirPods 4. Keep your AirPods 4 if their cancelling already does the job for you; every test found a step up, but not every tester found it a big one.

Will Music Sound Better?

Here the testers split most. The driver and amplifier carry over, and Apple credits a new multiport acoustic design and updated Adaptive EQ for richer sound. Tom’s Guide heard a big difference: its tester found the AirPods 4’s treble tinny and the AirPods 5 cleaner and better controlled in the bass, and called the newer pair “so much better” to listen to. Trusted Reviews agreed, especially on tracks that lean on bass punch. Gizmodo, which also switched between them, heard only a small difference, and BGR a small improvement, while AppleInsider wrote that the AirPods 5 “don’t sound noticeably different from AirPods 4”. What Hi-Fi, for its part, rated the AirPods 4’s sound highly in its review.

Even: decide on how your AirPods 4 sound to you now. If the top end strikes you as thin or harsh, the AirPods 5 are worth a listen; if you like them, testers can’t agree on how much would change, and the custom EQ both pairs gained with iOS 27 lets you adjust the balance yourself.

Will Your Battery Still Last the Day?

On paper nothing changes: Apple rates both for 4 hours a charge with cancelling on and 20 hours in total with the case. Independent rundowns of the AirPods 4 beat those figures: TechRadar measured 6.5 hours with cancelling on. With it off, SoundGuys measured 6 hours 21 minutes. No review we read had yet run the standard AirPods 5 down. Trusted Reviews ran the Wireless Charging Case model, rated an hour longer, to empty just after the five-hour mark with cancelling on, so not even the step-up model has been measured to outlast those AirPods 4 results.

Those AirPods 4 results came from new units. Batteries wear down with normal use, and Apple’s warranty doesn’t cover that, so a pair bought in 2024 may already run short of them.

Keep your AirPods 4 if they still cover your longest listening stretch; a new standard pair is rated no longer. Upgrade if yours now need the case before your commute or your working morning is over.

What Happens to Your Charging Case and Durability?

This is the change that catches AirPods 4 owners out. Your case charges on a Qi pad or an Apple Watch charger and has a speaker that plays a sound when you look for it in Find My. The standard AirPods 5 case has neither: it charges over USB-C only, and no cable comes in the box. The AirPods 5 with Wireless Charging Case bring both back, add a swipe on the stem for volume, which neither the AirPods 4 nor the standard AirPods 5 have, and are rated an hour longer per charge, for a little more than the standard model. Most reviews that covered both versions recommend that one, though SoundGuys saw little difference for the extra money; MacRumors calls it “clearly the one to buy for most people”, unless the earbuds are a secondary pair you won’t use often.

The build is tougher either way. The AirPods 5 and their case are rated IP57, against IP54 for the AirPods 4, so they are protected against a brief dunk in water rather than only sweat and splashes.

Upgrade if a tougher build appeals to you. If you charge on a pad or use the Find My speaker, look for the Wireless Charging Case version, the like-for-like replacement for your case; it is a separate listing from the standard AirPods 5 that this page’s buttons and prices show. The standard model is the cheaper choice if you need neither.

Consider Instead

Neither pair seals the ear, so neither suits someone who wants a long flight or a loud train to go quiet. For that, look at the AirPods Pro 3: silicone tips in five sizes seal the ear, Apple rates their cancelling at up to three times the AirPods 5’s and their battery at 8 hours a charge with it on, and a heart-rate sensor tracks workouts (our AirPods Pro 3 reviewour AirPods Pro 3 review). If you’ve moved to an Android phone, where both AirPods lose most of their extras, the Samsung Galaxy Buds 4 keep the open, tipless style and add a 9-band EQ. SoundGuys, setting them against the AirPods 4 with ANC, called them the better choice across platforms, though both AirPods cancelled more noise in its tests.

Upgrade to the AirPods 5 for More Quiet, a Tougher Build or a Fresh Battery

The AirPods 5 keep everything an AirPods 4 owner chose them for, the tipless fit, the cancelling and the easy iPhone pairing, and add stronger cancelling, an IP57 build and, to Tom’s Guide and Trusted Reviews, clearly better sound (Gizmodo heard a small difference, AppleInsider none). Upgrade now if more quiet on your commute, or the sound gain some testers heard, is worth it to you, or when your battery stops covering your day; if your pair still sounds and lasts fine to you, MacRumors’ view that there is no strong case to upgrade holds. The like-for-like upgrade is the AirPods 5 with Wireless Charging Case, the version most testers recommend: it keeps pad charging and the Find My speaker and adds swipe volume and an hour per charge. The buttons and prices on this page are for the standard model, which suits owners who don’t need those.

Upgrade or keep?

✓

The upgrade

Apple AirPods 5

Upgrade for more quiet, a tougher build or a fresh battery.

4.0/5SCORE

$129.00$174.99

Amazon ReviewsAmazon ReviewsRead our reviewRead our review

✓

Already own them

Apple AirPods 4 with ANC

Keep yours if they still last your listening day.

3.8/5SCORE

Discontinued

Read our reviewRead our review

Browse all Tech & Gadgets reviews →Tech & Gadgets reviews →

How We Compared

We compared the two on the questions an AirPods 4 owner faces before upgrading: noise cancelling, sound, battery, and the charging case and build. The facts about each pair come from the research behind our two reviews: Apple’s specification and support pages, plus independent tests and reviews from outlets including SoundGuys, TechRadar, TechGearLab, What Hi-Fi, Tom’s Guide, AppleInsider and Trusted Reviews. Tom’s Guide’s side-by-side test and the AirPods 4 vs AirPods 5 comparisons from MacRumors, What Hi-Fi and Gizmodo connect the two generations. We haven’t tested either pair ourselves; the scores are those of our reviews.